Search blog.co.uk

Labour Minister set to challenge election results in Court.

by shaz_the_prole @ 2007-05-06 - 00:07:38

The Scottish election was nail biting to say the least - each result ended in a neck and neck race between labour and the SNP for first place and the battle between the conservatives and the lib dems for 3rd place was just as fascinating. The end result was that the SNP won by 1 seat and this was reflected by the Conservatives beating the Lib Dems for 3rd place by just a single seat too.

I watched the results trickle in with great fascination. I live in the Cunninghame North constituency where Alan Wilson Labour Minister for Enterprise lost his seat by 48 votes, I had been speaking to people locally and was actually surprised that the result was so close as the majority I had spoken to had said they were voting SNP this time - I had therefore expected the gap between SNP and Labour to be much bigger than the 48 votes, but then we have the spoiled ballots to take into account so there is perhaps a chance that the gap was bigger.
The SNP made gains in North Ayrshire council too as did independents leaving no one party in over all control - some have welcomed this as a victory in what they have referred to as the 'smashing of the labour nepotism ring' in Irvine ( seat of the council), if such a ring existed or not can be debated however public perception is that such a ring did exist.

The Big story though is that of Alan Wilson losing his seat to Kenneth Gibson of the SNP - Labour have now suggested that Mr Wilson will challenge this result in the courts - I think if he does and it forces a bi-election here - Mr Wilson may well be in for a shock, such a case may well be interpreted locally as sour grapes at losing his job - this ofcourse means that Mr Wilsons staff in the Kilbirnie office will also be losing their jobs - If I am correct that means that at least one of Mr Wilsons relatives. If Mr Wilson takes this case to court I am wondering what he can expect to achieve - another election across Scotland? This was not the only constituency that had a large number of spoiled ballots - they all did. Some very unexpected results were obtained such as Tommy Sheridan losing his seat - could it be the case that all of Tommys votes needed for a seat were in that number of spoiled ballots and lost postal votes? Mr Wilson could well be setting up a domino effect across Scotland with this challenge - its not over yet for anyone by a long shot. What is apparent is that the SNP have won the popular vote right across the country in both parliament and the councils and we can summise that in those spoiled papers there will be a very simillar reflection of the ballots which were actually counted - if this is the case Mr Wilson will achieve nothing but a waste of tax payers money - can he not just bow out gracefully like Tommy Sheridan and say 'theres always next time'.

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

joebanglesjoebangles [Member]
06/05/07 @ 00:13

If we ever get to know the truth I think that you will find that the Scottish Labour party are behind this challenge.

wowbaggerwowbagger pro
06/05/07 @ 13:10

But would Scottish Labour really want to open this can of worms? A sucessful challenge would set a precedent that may end in the number of seats they hold increasing but the cost would be their credibility, rightly or not, as the governing party when the new voting process was instigated the perception must be that it's their screw up that resulted in this travesty. Of course, being politicians, thay may take the view that power now, if it can be achieved by a challenge, is the only game in town and that the electorates collective memory will not stretch back to this shambles when the next election rolls around and if it does, well hey, we've had another period in charge. Did my cynicism just squash my earlier arguement?

joebanglesjoebangles [Member]
06/05/07 @ 16:01

The Labour Party have had that smirk wiped off of their faces, they have believed for too many years that they have the right to rule in Scotland, now they will do anything, behind closed doors, because that is the way that they work, to keep hold of that power by blaming everybody and anyone except themselves.

shaz_the_proleshaz_the_prole [Member]
08/05/07 @ 20:15

I agree with both of you, it is blatantly obvious that Scottish Labour are behind the challenge and it is also true that this could create a domino effect across Scotland. I think that IF we are forced into another election through court challenges it will manifest itself as a very low turnout and yet the result will be the same. The spoiled ballot issue is the fault of Labour who as the Scottish executive chose to ignore advice and protests from other political parties concerning introducing an STV system for council elections on the same day as the parliamentary elections - I think labour were counting on the confusion to swing things their way - it backfired!

shaz_the_proleshaz_the_prole [Member]
30/05/07 @ 21:36

Alan Wilson has decided not to challenge the results of this election. This means that the fiasco which was the 2007 Scottish Parliamentary will now be sorted out entirely by the structures in place to monitor and oversee elections in Scotland.

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.